Every few years, fashion performs one of its most magical tricks: it convinces us that something we once swore we'd never wear again is suddenly irresistible. For spring 2026, that honour belongs to the gloriously divisive category of 'ugly shoes' with fisherman sandals proudly leading the way.
Yes, those practical, cage-like leather contraptions once associated with seaside holidays and sensible uncles are back and absolutely thriving. Fashion insiders are pairing them with tailored trousers, micro minis, and yes - even socks.
The appeal? Comfort, for one. After years of teetering on minimalist straps and questionably engineered soles, our feet are collectively sighing in relief. Fisherman sandals offer structure, support, and the reassuring feeling that you could, if needed, actually walk somewhere quite far away sans blisters.
© GC ImagesThen there's the charm of the ugly-meets-cute aesthetic. Think chunky soles, awkward silhouettes and practicality vibes. Wearing something objectively clunky is officially cool.
Of course, fisherman sandals aren't alone. They're joined by other formerly maligned footwear - bulky sports sandals, cork footbeds and foam sliders. Together they form a wonderfully weird lineup that prioritises personality over polish.
© Getty ImagesAnd of course, there is the celeb stamp of approval, coming from official Cool-girls Hailey Bieber and Katie Holmes. And so reader, I admit defeat. These sandals that I swore I would never sink my feet into are going straight onto my shopping list for spring 2026.
As H! Fashion's Fashion Features Editor and trend expert Tania Leslau notes: "Originally designed to protect the feet of fishermen navigating slippery decks, these water-draining sandals have been reimagined by designers who revel in the irony of ugly fashion."
© GC Images"Today, the divisive silhouettes are the epitome of functional style, with their chunky soles and thick leather straps lending a nostalgic yet boyish appeal to outfits that straddle the line between rugged and refined."
So, if you find yourself eyeing up a pair and potentially making a purchase - don't worry, you're in good company and best of all - I've rounded up the most fantastic pairs you can get your mitts on right now.
Best fisherman sandals to buy now
Ellis Sandals
Vagabond
Vagabond are known for their sturdy shoes that will elevate any ensemble. Team with red socks.
Leather Fisherman Sandals
Marks & Spencer
Because picking up a pair of sensible sandals at Marks & Spencer just feels right.
Steve Mono Maypole Sandals
Toast
The rich toffee shade and contrast stitching make this pair perfect for teaming with denim.
Sena Square Toe Fisherman Sandals
Hush
I am a big fan of the square toe on this cream offering.
Thatcher Fisherman
Schuh
This soft caramel colour would look dreamy with tailored trousers for hot days in the office.
Cross Strap Espadrille Sandal
Jigsaw
An espadrille take on the classic fisherman breaths summer-holiday energy into the staple.
Buttercup Leather Sandal
Penelope Chilvers
A more feminine take on the classic, born to be worn with a floaty frock.
Black Freya Fisherman Sandal
Whistles
The perfect sunny-day go to, this pristine pair boast a moulded footbed for extra comfort.
How I chose the pieces:
Style: I opted for the best range of styles to suit different sizes, all of which could be styled for both day and night.
Price: I aimed for a range of price points without compromising on quality and of course, unabashed ugliness.
HELLO!'s selection is editorial and independently chosen – we only feature items our editors love and approve of. Best Quality Designer Handbag may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. To find out more visit our FAQ page.
